Read + Write + Report
Home | Start a blog | About Orble | FAQ | Blogs | Writers | My Orble | Login
 
"I RECOGNISE TERROR AS THE FINEST EMOTION AND SO I WILL TRY TO TERRORISE THE READER. BUT IF I CANNOT TERRIFY, I WILL TRY TO HORRIFY, AND IF I CANNOT HORRIFY, I'LL GO FOR THE GROSS-OUT. I'M NOT PROUD." --- STEPHEN KING ::::::::::::: Spoilers for plot points and resolutions can occur within my movie reviews with or without warning. Read at your own risk.

The Strangers

December 19th 2008 01:29
The Strangers movie poster
This movie was very disappointing, and it really annoyed me too. I’ll admit I had high expectations; I had originally caught cyber-wind of it a while back and it sounded good, I liked the trailer, and two close friends saw it on the big screen and were very impressed (albeit they don't really watch horror movies). I had meant to see it in the cinema, but missed its brief run, in the interim I saw the brilliant French-Romanian Ils (Them, 2006) and wondered if The Strangers (2008) was some kind of American re-envisioning.

As it turns out The Strangers was originally penned two years before Them (under the title The Faces). Like Them, The Strangers claims to be based on real events (whereas Them deals with an event that was documented in European media, The Strangers is inspired by a less sensational event that occurred in director Bryan Bertino’s neighbourhood when he was a boy). The whole “true story” angle is always meant to add dramatic-thriller gravitas to a movie, and if it’s a horror movie then even better.

The Strangers opening scrawl about 1.4 million violent crimes in the States every year is pointless, and hardly surprising, but the statement “the brutal events that took place are still not entirely known” scuttles the entire movie … and it's confusing as well, especially after you’ve watched the extended DVD version (more on that later).
The Strangers Scott Speedman
Scott Speedman as James
James Hoyt (Scott Speedman) and his (would-be) fiancée Kristen McKay (Liv Tyler) arrive at James’ parents secluded home off the main road. It’s 4am, and they’ve both been at a wedding reception. They have the house to themselves. It’s revealed that James proposed to Kristen and she turned him down.
The Strangers Liv Tyler
Liv Tyler as Kristen
They mope around; Kristen takes a bath and reflects on the awkward moment back at the party, James peels the top off a tub of ice cream and cracks the champagne he’d had on ice in anticipation of a celebratory nightcap. The two eventually begin to make-out in commiseration, as you do, when suddenly there’s a loud knock at the door.
The Strangers Gemma Ward
Aussie model Gemma Ward as Dollface
A young blonde woman, her face half in shadow, asks for "Tamara", then leaves. James and Kristen are a little bewildered. Kristen has run out of cigarettes, so James offers to drive to the nearest all-nighter to get some. In his absence the blonde girl returns to knock loudly at the front door, but now she’s joined by two others. The three strangers become assailants, each disguised behind a mask: the blonde girl in a doll-face mask, a brunette girl in a glam pin-up mask, and a tall guy in a sack mask. They begin to terrorise Kristen, and once James returns they continue to terrorise the couple ‘til dawn …
The Strangers Scott Speedman and Liv Tyler
A house invasion warrants the use of dad's shotgun and the hidden stash of ammo
Writer/director Bryan Betino is skilled in the visual narrative department, but his screenplay is thoroughly frustrating, and irritating to boot. It doesn’t help that I’m not a fan of either of the two leads who are renowned for whispering their lines and looking perpetually angst or forlorn. The three “psychopaths” - Dollface (Gemma Ward), Pin-Up Girl (Laura Mangolis) and Man in the Mask (Kip Weeks), as they’re credited - are never properly revealed, although Gemma Ward’s unusual face is partially seen when she’s at the front door (although at this point the audience doesn’t know she’s one of the assailants). The other two are briefly glimpsed, but not enough to establish their looks.

SPOILER ALERT!

I have too many gripes; the blurb at the beginning which states the events are not entirely known suggests Kristen and James do not survive, yet Kristen is seen regaining consciousness and screaming at the very end (in a Carrie moment) as a Mormon boy who'd been passing by reaches out to touch her, so theoretically she’d be able to tell police everything unless she’s so traumatized she can’t remember.

Kristen is obviously so ignorant she doesn’t know that when you plug a mobile phone in to re-charge you can operate it immediately, unless its completely dead, then you’d only need to wait a few minutes (the whole mobile phone out of range/dead battery conceit in movies is starting to grate on me). Why the hell didn’t she call 911 on the landline instead of James anyway?!
The Strangers Glen Howerton
Mike (Glen Howerton) turns up in the nick of time ... 5am!
All these implausible elements bugged the hell out of me; the assailants have chosen three particularly difficult masks to see out of and yet they keep them on the entire time (apart from the very end) and manage to do all manner of stalking, chasing, and elaborate maneuvering throughout the movie with no hint of any hindrance.

The assailants, who are supposedly serial killers because one of the girls tells the other “It’ll be easier next time”, reveal themselves to the two Mormon boys on the roadside (one of the girls takes their religious pamphlet, admitting that she sins from time to time), then drive away only metres away from the murder crime scene which the boys then discover; real smart serial killers, these ones!
The Strangers Liv Tyler
Aha, the ol' hide-in-the-slatted-closet trick
Even more infuriating is in the "unrated and extended" DVD version (a whole extra minute or so, but no more blood!), after Kristen crawls to get the male killer's forgotten mobile phone ringing on the floor, the male killer returns but decides not to finish her off. Yeah, these eccentric killers are real professionals.

And what’s James’ wedding buddy Mike deciding to come to pick James up early at 5am?! And no neighbours, even if they were several hundred metres away, heard the shotgun being fired several times in the early hours of the morning?! James does mention he's heard no cars or dogs, but that's a bit too bloody convenient for the killers isn't it, especially when Dollface reasons matter-of-factly with James and Kristen "'Cos you were home".
The Strangers Liv Tyler and Laura Mangolis
Pin Up Girl (Laura Mangolis) lets Kristen squirm a little
Perhaps I’m being particularly picky on this movie, but I couldn’t help but compare it to other horror movies using similar tactics to much better effect. Every time I saw the masked assailants standing in the background or in long shot trying to look ominous I thought of Michael Myers, and how much scarier he was. And when James and Kristen were holed-up with the gun acting desperate I thought of Sam Peckinpah’s Straw Dogs (1971) and how that was far more tense and frantic.

And then there’s Them, which deals with very similar circumstances (couple terrorized in house by unknown assailants), yet does it with oodles more style and more plausibility. And it’s a damn sight scarier than The Strangers, which is just riddled with clichés.
The Strangers Gemma Ward, Kip Weeks, Laura Manglolis, Liv Tyler, Scott Speedman
Kip Weeks realises he doesn't look nearly as cute as his killer accomplices
It’s curious but the three masked killers in The Strangers never once gave me the chills; their noisy, calculated antics only seemed to annoy me. Yet the hooded assailants in Them, and Michael Myers of course, I found to be genuinely terrifying. For once the attempt at realism didn’t pack the punch I thought it might. It’s the supernatural veneer and edge of Them and Halloween that works so much better.

Here's the trailer:

105
Vote


   

   

   


Comments
9 Comments. [ Add A Comment ]

Comment by Damo

December 19th 2008 02:45
damn Bryn I was going to rent this one over the holidays.
Now I am reluctant to do so.


Comment by Bryn

December 19th 2008 04:11
Rent Them instead ... there's no blood and gore, so you might be able to talk the wife into watching it with you, and she can squeeze your hand when the going gets tough

Comment by Damo

December 19th 2008 06:50
Bryn

If it also has Latin Dancing she will make me watch it.

Comment by Bryn

December 19th 2008 07:52
No Latin Dancing I'm afraid. You'd best watch it on your lonesome. It's better that way.

Comment by Anonymous

December 19th 2008 18:32
I laughed this entire movie. It was so hilariously bad.

The masks all looked so silly, especially Mr. Potato-Sack-Head who made me giggle every time he appeared.

I also didn't feel any sympathy for the main characters because their tactics at surviving were so morbidly retarded that I wanted them to be captured and gutted to simply keep them from giving birth to any retarded children.

This movie boiled down to 2 retards trapped in a house being chased around by 3 of the WORST, most inefficient killers of all time.

Oh boy.

Comment by Journeywoman

December 19th 2008 22:32
I'll agree that there were a ton of plotholes, and I could barely understand what Scott Speedman was saying half the time... but I still found it scary! There are a lot of ways that it could have been scarier though, and you're right, as far as serial killers go they were a pretty erratic trio.

There were moments, though, where I nearly jumped out of my skin - for example, when Kristen's hiding in the pantry and pinup girl suddenly appears... shudder.

But I'm a Liv Tyler fan so I guess I'm biased there

Comment by Anonymous

December 20th 2008 18:41
Yeah, I haven't seen "Them" and I had high hopes for this film as well, and I still hated it. Everything you said was wrong with it, I had formed the same opinion about before reading this article-- with the exception of your comment about the shotgun.

Having grown up in the country, I can safely say that hearing a shotgun go off at 5AM (assuming anyone else who WAS near enough was awake at 5AM to hear it), isn't that uncommon or worrisome. Hunters get up early because the animals are still sleepy and less alert. Some people just like to get up early, and some of those people may happen to be target-practicing (a bit of a stretch, but not at all implausible).

It was decently acted on Tyler and Speedman's parts, but there wasn't really anything scary about this film. Just largely annoying.

Comment by Bryn

December 22nd 2008 22:18
Great comments everyone ... I like it when horrorphiles get stirred up.

Comment by _CIA

December 28th 2008 11:28
I agree, the boyfriend was a thick-head so I am not surprised she was still looking. A little too trick'a'treat for me. But worth a watch...2&1/2 stars.

Add A Comment

To create a fully formatted comment please click here.


CLICK HERE TO LOGIN | CLICK HERE TO REGISTER

Name or Orble Tag
Home Page (optional)
Comments
Bold Italic Underline Strikethrough Separator Left Center Right Separator Quote Insert Link Insert Email
Notify me of replies
Notify extra people about this comment
Is this a private comment?
List the Email Addresses or Orble Tags of the people you would like to be notified about this comment


One per line max of 30

List the Email Addresses or Orble Tags of the people you would like to be notified about this private comment thread. Only the people in this list will be able to see or reply to your comment.


One per line max of 30

Your Name
(for the email going out to the above list, it can be different to your Orble Tag)
Your Email Address
(optional)
(required for reply notification)
Submit
More Posts
5 Posts
12 Posts
12 Posts
720 Posts dating from August 2006
Email Subscription
Receive e-mail notifications of new posts on this blog:
0
Moderated by Bryn
Copyright © 2006 2007 2008 On Topic Media PTY LTD. All Rights Reserved. Design by Vimu.com.
On Topic Media ZPages: Sydney |  Melbourne |  Brisbane |  London |  Birmingham |  Leeds     [ Advertise ] [ Contact Us ] [ Privacy Policy ]